The Goddess of Freedom

Posted October 12, 2004
This article appeared in the Summer 2003 issue of the Claremont Review of Books. Click here to send a comment.
Print This
The statue appears in many contexts; an Iraqi boy holds a tiny version in a news photo; Chinese students in Tiananmen Square build a replica. Many vulgar advertisements use the image. Why is this work, unveiled in 1886, so popular?

Because the statue represents a goddess, and goddesses are worshipped. We know she's a goddess. Her ideal proportions, her majestic garments, the torch she carries, and her colossal scale are indications of that.

Furthermore, she stands on a pedestal. Mortals don't stand on pedestals. It might be the case that Lady Liberty is our last goddess. Modern science has convinced us that such beings are childish fantasies, and a waste of public resources. Modern statues don't have pedestals. Our pictures have no frames. The idea of a transcendent reality is no more; now every object in the universe shares equal status with every other object. Everything is equally mundane.

But the creators of Liberty shunned the mundane; they lived heroically, and Liberty is evidence of their passion.

The statue originated in the mind of a French statesman, Laboulaye (1811-1883), in the aftermath of his country's defeat in the Franco-Prussian War. The loser in that war was the emperor, Napoleon III; the winner became the German emperor, Wilhelm I. When it came time to decide a new constitution for France, Laboulaye wanted no more emperors. He opted for a republic, and the gift of the statue to the United States was a political gesture designed to nudge French public opinion in the republican direction. A like-minded sculptor, Auguste Bartholdi (1834-1904), was given the commission. The title of the work is "Liberty Enlightening the World."

It is doubtful if Bartoldi's work was ever taken seriously by the cognoscenti. From an art historical point of view he was, in fact, something of a dinosaur. A contemporary such as Claude Monet (1840-1926) is now much better known and appreciated. In the aftermath of the war that inflamed the patriotism of Bartholdi, Monet went to England and to Holland, where he painted windmills and canals, subjects that might appeal to the tourist or vacationer. Later, he withdrew a bit further, and concentrated on haystacks. Finally, he did waterlillies. But he wasn't really painting waterlillies: he was painting countless impressions of blue and green and gray that, for some reason, took his fancy.

When we compare Liberty to Monet's paintings, it's hard to believe that their creators were fellow citizens and contemporaries. Most of us have forgotten the name of Bartholdi. But the boy in Iraq and the students in China are not waving posters of haystacks and waterlillies.

About the Authors

Elliott Banfield, and artist who lives and works in New York,  is art director of the Claremont Review of Books. His website is www.elliottbanfield.com.


Archives_Button

 Subscribe_Button


Renew_Button

My Claremont Login


Stay up to date with the Claremont Institute events, programs, and publications most important to you. Claremont Review of Books subscribers receive complete online access from the first day an issue is published. Please login below or click here to sign-up.

E-mail
Password

Support the Claremont Review of Books

Like other journals of opinion, the Claremont Review of Books depends on the generosity of friends. Your contribution to the CRB allows us to continue our important work.

To make a tax-deductible contribution, please click here or call Bob Gransden at (909) 621-6825.

Search the Site

 

E-mail Newsletter

Enter your email address below to stay informed about Claremont Institute events and scholarship.

 

Copyright © 2002-2013 The Claremont Institute. Technical problems may be brought to the attention of the webmaster.  

 Terms & Conditions    Privacy Statement